Cost of Garage Door Replacement vs Repair

As a garage door ages and faces wear and tear there is a constant balance between the price of repair and outright replacement. No-one wants to spend more than they need to but at some point it makes more economic sense to get an entirely new garage door installed.

The decision to replace a garage door can significantly impact your home's value, your family's safety, and your monthly budget. So what are the factors that influence this choice and how do you go about making an informed decision?

The Garage Door Replacement Basics

Before we dive into the costs, let's clarify the key components of a garage door. A typical garage door consists of:

• Panels: These are the individual sections that make up the door's surface.
• Tracks: These are the metal channels that guide the panels as they open and close.
• Springs: These provide the tension necessary to lift and lower the door.
• Cables: These connect the springs to the panels, ensuring smooth operation.
• Operator: This is the motor that powers the opening and closing of the door.

Factors Affecting Repair or Replacement Costs

There are multiple factors that influence the cost of replacing or repairing your garage door, from the age and condition of the current parts to the size and style of the door. Older doors may require extensive repairs while replacing large or non-standard size doors can also be expensive. The material of the door will influence both repair and replacement costs while the complexity of any unusual setups can also increase labor costs.

Some areas will also come with their own concerns, whether that’s the availability of materials or the need for permits or inspections that may be required for replacement but not repair.

Common Garage Door Repair Costs

Replacing a broken spring is a relatively common repair and the cost to repair will depend on the type of spring and the labor involved. Cables can become worn over time and break, needing replacement to ensure the door operates safely. Bent or damaged tracks can cause excessive noise or the door to fail to open.

The panels may need repair or replacement if they crack or become dented as this can not only impact the insulation of your garage but also potentially the operation and security of your door. Garage door openers can also fail through fault, lack of repair or just wear and tear, needing repair or potentially replacement.

Garage Door Replacement Costs

The cost of replacing a garage door will vary depending on the factors mentioned earlier. However, you can expect to pay several thousand dollars for a new door, including installation.

When to Repair and When to Replace

Here are some guidelines to help you decide whether to repair or replace your garage door:

• Age of the Door: If your door is more than 20 years old, it may be more cost-effective to replace it.
• The Extent of Damage: If the damage is extensive or if multiple components need to be repaired, replacement may be a better option.
• Energy Efficiency: Newer garage doors are often more energy-efficient than older models so potential energy savings should be factored in.
• Aesthetics: If you want to improve the appearance of your home, a new garage door can make a significant difference.
• Safety: If your garage door is no longer operating safely, it's time to replace it.

Additional Considerations

When purchasing a new garage door, make sure the manufacturer offers a warranty to give you peace of mind over your new purchase. Newer doors likely have better insulation and won’t have any damage that may be compromising the insulation they do have - replacement can help reduce energy costs, as well as minimizing external noise. Replacing a door is a good chance to get the style you want, a garage door can play a significant role in the overall look of your home and impact the curb appeal.

The decision to repair or replace your garage door is a significant one. By carefully considering the factors discussed in this article, you can make an informed choice that will benefit your home and your family. If you're still unsure, don't hesitate to consult with a local garage door repair professional for personalized advice.